Tuesday , November 21 2017
Free Online Courses
Home / News / Collins and Murkowski stood up for women over the threats of males.

Collins and Murkowski stood up for women over the threats of males.

Sen. Susan Collins gave an eloquent protection of Planned Parenthood in her assertion on the failed Obamacare repeal.

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

Two feminine senators, maybe the most average Republicans in the Senate, have gotten many well-deserved thank-yous for going towards their get together and voting down a “skinny” repeal of Obamacare late Thursday night time. Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska have stood stalwart towards a number of situations of GOP B.S. this yr, together with the Senate’s preliminary Obamacare repeal try and Betsy DeVos’ nomination as Secretary of Education.

Christina Cauterucci is a Slate employees author.

But their votes on Thursday got here at a very essential second, underneath excessive strain and gendered assaults from members of their very own get together. One unforgivably doofy Republican Congressman from Texas stated on a radio present that he want to have a duel-to-the-death with the “female senators” who stood in the means of Obamacare repeal, however since they’re however women, he would maintain himself again. (Wonder if he’d roll again that assertion now that John McCain, a verifiable man, forged the last, deciding vote towards the laws.) When requested about Murkowski and Collins, a Republican Congressman from Georgia stated somebody ought to “snatch a knot in [the Senate’s] ass,” which means hit them. Trump particularly focused Murkowski on Twitter, riling up his supporters to go after her, and the Secretary of the Interior threatened to cease Alaska drilling tasks if she didn’t vote the president’s method.

Weaker legislators may need caught to the get together line in defiance of their consciences. (See: the Republican senators who stated they’d solely vote for the invoice in the event that they received a assure that it wouldn’t turn out to be regulation.) Standing up to a crowd of friends making glib references to bodily violence and actual threats to legislative priorities couldn’t have been straightforward.

Braver nonetheless was Collins’ public assertion on why she voted towards the invoice. She makes arguments towards each the Affordable Care Act as is and the plans Senate Republicans have proposed, then outlines a key purpose for her opposition to the payments her friends wrote: the provision that may have prevented Planned Parenthood from getting reimbursed for any providers offered to sufferers on Medicaid, who make up greater than half the health group’s shopper base. Collins’ protection of Planned Parenthood was as correct and passionate as any Democrat’s must be, far past the compassion or psychological capability of her male contemporaries in the GOP:

Millions of women throughout the nation depend on Planned Parenthood for household planning, most cancers screening, and primary preventive health care providers. Denying women entry to Planned Parenthood not solely runs opposite to our objective of letting sufferers select the health care supplier who most closely fits their wants, nevertheless it additionally might impede well timed entry to care.

If Planned Parenthood have been defunded, different household planning clinics in Maine, together with group health facilities, would see a 63 % improve of their affected person load. Some sufferers would wish to drive larger distances to obtain care, whereas others must wait longer for an appointment.

Collins additionally did away with the persistent right-wing lie that federal taxpayer cash is funding abortions:

Let me be clear that this isn’t about abortion. Federal regulation already prohibits the use of federal funds to pay for abortion besides in instances of rape, incest, or when the life of the mom is in danger.

This is about interfering with the capacity of a lady to decide on the health care supplier who is true for her. This dangerous provision should not have any place in laws that purports to be about restoring affected person decisions and freedom.

It’s so unnerving to learn an trustworthy, humane evaluation of women’s health care from a Republican! Murkowski, too, has been a vocal supporter of Planned Parenthood’s continued eligibility for Medicaid reimbursements and federal family-planning grants. This in spite of the very actual danger that being women advocating for so-called women’s points might additional alienate Republican males in the Senate who didn’t even assume women belonged at the drafting desk in the first place. Together, with their adjoining desks, Collins and Murkowski have confirmed that feminine legislators have some of the strongest spines in Congress. That power is available in numbers, even when that quantity is 2.


Source link